Skip to Main Content

PrepTest 73, Passage 1, Setup


Carl Pyrdum
Lesson by Carl Pyrdum
Magoosh Expert

Summary
The passage provides a critical examination of the debate between Darwin's theory of evolution and the strict constructionists' perspective, focusing on the role of natural selection and adaptive mutations.
  • Darwin's view on evolution emphasizes that it is not solely driven by selection, contrasting with the strict constructionists who argue that evolution equates to selection.
  • The author critiques the strict constructionists' stance by highlighting the existence of non-adaptive mutations, which contradicts their theory that all changes must be adaptive for reproductive success.
  • Examples of non-adaptive alterations and the Cretaceous extinction are used to further challenge the strict constructionists' views, demonstrating scenarios where their theory does not hold.
  • The author employs a disjunctive proof to argue against the strict constructionists, suggesting their assumptions are flawed.
  • Ultimately, the passage sides with Darwin's broader view of evolution, critiquing the narrow interpretation of evolution as merely selection by the strict constructionists.
Chapters
00:00
Introduction to the Evolution Debate
00:39
Critique of Strict Constructionists' View
01:20
Examples Against Strict Constructionists
01:49
Conclusion and Author's Stance